Progeny testing is essential in recurrent selection because:
Phenotype of a single cross-pollinated plant poorly reflects its transmitting ability because heterozygosity, dominance, and micro-environment mask genotype. Superior appearance may result from favorable interlocus interactions or non-heritable environmental boost, not additive alleles that can be passed to progeny. Progeny testing evaluates half-sib or S1 families derived from selected plant in replicated trials, providing estimate of breeding value, general combining ability, and heritability. In recurrent selection, selected S1 plants are selfed and testcrossed to a common tester; progeny m
Ref: Lush JL. Animal Breeding Plans; Acquaah Chapter 13 – importance of progeny testing in recurrent selection