Skip to content

Rocket Valves Explained: Controlled Explosion, Falcon 9 Merlin 65 L/s, Raptor 600 L/s, Cryogenic -253°C, 400 Bar, 20G Shock, Ball Vs Balanced Poppet Vs Blade Valve, Pneumatic Helium Vs Hydraulic Vs EMA

Rocket Is Controlled Explosion - You Only Control Propellant Flow

  • Rocket is controlled explosion, you control only one vector, propellant flow.
  • Whole wiring mess is just propellant flow management system.
  • Rockets mostly go boom because of valve failure, flow rate is massive.
  • Building-size valves can handle that flow for 50-60 years, rocket must do it under pressure.
  • 1950s rockets were tank + cartridge + piston pushing propellant, hope for best, we don't do that now.
  • Primary control is turbopump power, gas generator flame controls main flame, you never touch main flame directly.

You Only Control Propellant, Nothing Else

Hello readers, we're going to talk about rocket valves. So let's dive deep into it. So what exactly is the need here? Well, rockets are what we call controlled explosion. Now explosion part does make sense, it's like, but it is controlled. And when you, what do you mean by control? What are you exactly controlling?

You are only controlling one vector or two fluids most of the time, which is propellant flow. There is almost nothing more than that. You are just controlling propellant. Everything else, the whole wiring mess, whole stuff, is just propellant flow management system. So you have to control that, and why it is so hard.

Flow Rate Is Brutal - 65 L/s To 600 L/s

Why rockets mostly keep going boom because of valve failure? Because flow rate is massive, like most people do not have understanding of what sort of flow rate we are talking about. And can we have a valve? Yes, the valve is size of a building. There are valves that can handle that, and they do that for like 50-60 years. It's just that rocket has to do that under pressure.

So like, for example, Falcon 9, a small rocket comparatively speaking, its Merlin engine can drink up to 65 L of propellant per second. Imagine 65 L, and imagine that flowing in a second. Now let's talk about some big puppies. Raptor. Raptor can drink almost 600 L per second, like that will, it's like one, two, swimming pool full, like it is brutal, the amount of flow.

And again, how can you do that? Well, all simple, just increase the pressure, just increase the flow rate velocity, all of those just goes out of the door, it's stupid. And the primary means of controlling these puppies as an engine is turbopump power. Basically, how turbopump is being run, that's where you control it.

It's like, I'm going to control turbopump power source, as in the gas generators. Basically, that flame is what you control. Result of that flame is this flame. You do not directly touch that flame. You can't, so you just control the gas generators. How do you do that? Valves. And that's how we manage the rocket. So need is like, this is a control system.

There used to be, like, not joking, there used to be some very 1950s rockets, where it's like, okay, it was just a tank with a cartridge that went boom, keep pushing, like piston pushing the propellant and all that, just hope for the best. We don't do that anymore. We have valves now.

Brutal Constraints - Cryogenic, Heat, 400 Bar, 20G, Zero Drop, 15 Hz

  • Cryogenic shock survival first, hydrogen -253°C, coldest, liquid oxygen is boiling from hydrogen point of view.
  • Structural steel must handle pressure while at cryogenic temperature, thousands of alloys shrink to few.
  • High temperature resilience, turbopump fuel controls few inches away from fire, engine bell still emits ginormous thermal flux.
  • Burst pressure starts at 400 bar, liquid at 400-500 bar is completely different demon than gas.
  • Must handle 20G shocks minimum, acoustic bounce back, Max Q, stage separation boom events.
  • 400 bar in must be 400 bar out, minimal pressure drop, no cavitation, no erosion.
  • Fast response 15 Hz minimum, sinusoidal curve not square wave, encoder feedback always.
  • All this while being light as possible, bidding pool goes from 500 companies to 5 companies.

Cryogenic Shock - Hydrogen -253°C

So what are the constraints that valve must work inside, otherwise there is no point? So first, cryogenic shock survival. Now, God help you if you touch hydrogen, because that puppy goes to -253°C. The coldest. That is so goddamn cold. Liquid oxygen is boiling from hydrogen's point of view. So, yeah, it's brutal. There is only few companies that can even touch that.

And be mindful. It's not that, oh, I have a structural steel that can handle that. It's like, can that structural steel handle it while being under pressure, while being that cryogenic temperature? Yeah. The list of metal goes like, we have thousands of alloys. The moment you put that constraint, it's like, yeah, thankfully more and more people are switching away from it. So things are far more relaxed.

Because again, liquid methane and liquid oxygen, that's boiling compared to that. What if you do need it, like SLS or Space Shuttle, it is painful. And also you have to have high temperature resilience. Now this part may be confusing, is generally turbopumps, fuel control systems are few inches away from lateral fire. So that engine bell, even though it has adaptive cooling, it does not mean it's not an emitter of a ginormous amount of thermal flux, it's still hot.

And not to mention, even if that is not, you still have fire like few millimeters away, like you know, that whoosh is radiating everything back, so you have to tolerate it. And sometimes, like especially in Merlin designs, you may be directly trying to control the hot exhaust flow, as in, like, in the engine, not the outside, in the engine, gas generator do create a scenario where you might require some valve to control it, not completely stop it, because that will boom the engine, but you may want to throttle it, so to say, so that is difficult.

Pressure - Liquid At 400-500 Bar Is Different Demon

And pressure-wise, we are talking high pressure, so generally you're talking about burst pressure rating that is very robust, we start at like 400 bar. To give you a context, generally CNG tanks in India, they are rated for around 300 bar. Of course they can handle it, it's just 300 bar is their system. Now if you buy a hydrogen car, they generally go up to 600 bar. However, that's a gas. We are talking about liquid. Liquid at 400 bar or 500 bar, that's a completely different demon.

You like, even minor speed fluctuation will create oscillation that will destroy everything. So, it is something that is difficult. Another aspect, it must handle while being shaken apart violently, at almost 20G of rating is minimal. Like it must be able to handle shocks of 20G, like it's a normal day, because again, when you launch the rocket, like when it's next to the pad, there's lot of acoustic bounce back, no matter how much water suppression you have, it does not eliminate the sound, it just like tames it.

But again, you still have to design in such a way that, what if the water deluge system was not working? And even if water deluge did its job, and sound acoustic was not a problem, you still have the rocket itself shaking, and when it goes through Max Q, or like, you know, engine separation, there are a lot of boom events that are putting shocks. So you must handle 20G shocks, like, bro, like, if you fail before 20G, it's like, they will just throw it away. So 20G.

Zero Pressure Drop, No Cavitation, No Erosion

And all your valves ideally should have what we classify as minimal pressure drop, meaning if it is flowing at 400 bar, it must go to the other end at 400 bar. It should not just convert everything to gas by heating it up. It must have as minimal flow drop as possible. So you can't just have industrial geometry. Most of the industrial valves, they do have very high pressure drop. In this sort of scenario, you can't have pressure drop.

Ideally, again, if you can't help it, you can't help it. But if you can help it, you generally work your ass off to make sure the pressure drop is negligible. So, while making sure there is no cavitation erosion. Cavitation is again, you are talking about bubbles, they boil and expand like bonkers. So if you have brutal design, or like something that creates too much turbulence, yeah, cavitation would be bad. So there is that, and then you have erosion.

So if you have too much surface area that is exposed, when you have hundreds of meter per second of fluid flowing through it, it will just grind away anything. Dust going to turbopump or fuel generator, gas generator, kaboom. So yeah, it's a tough margin. And it must have fast response time with encoders.

15 Hz, Sinusoidal Curve, Encoder Feedback

Response time, as in, generally it says like, 15 hertz is minimum, like minimum. Your control computer should be able to command this like, 15 times a second minimum. Some may be even faster. It's just that we can't make it super fast, because liquid does take time to react. And again, there are certain things that you do not want to do to liquid. You do want like, you know, sinusoidal curve, not square wave curve, because if you do square wave, it will boil off the fluid. So it is unwise.

And to make sure that it is actually happening, you always have encoder feedbacks. All the valves in a computer, that's why systems can, you know, we commanded the valve to open, it did not open. How the heck they knew that it did not open? All valves in rocketry system generally have feedback loop. Dumb valves will have like, you know, limit switch, where it's like on-off. If it's a throttlable, it will have like full travel system, like how much it open, how much it closed, and nowadays it's cheap enough to, like almost everything has full travel range encoder, it's cheap.

So that's response with a feedback, and all of this you have to do, all of this, be mindful, there is even more list. NASA has published a documentation since 1978, PDF is scanned recently, and it's available, it's like 200 pages of details, so there is more of that, while being light as possible. So, can you meet all of this? Yes. Can you meet all of this while being light? Yeah. Your bidding pool will go from 500 companies to five companies. It's like, yeah, that's, they are the only ones stupid enough to try. So, there are brutal constraints.

Constraint Number / Limit Why It Is Hard
Cryogenic Hydrogen -253°C, LOX boiling vs hydrogen Steel must hold pressure + cryo, few alloys survive
Heat Few inches / few mm from fire, thermal flux Engine bell cooling still radiates, gas generator throttle
Pressure Burst from 400 bar, liquid 400-500 bar, CNG 300 bar, H2 car 600 bar gas Minor fluctuation creates oscillation that destroys
Shock 20G minimum Acoustic bounce, Max Q, separation booms, deluge may fail
Pressure drop 400 bar in = 400 bar out, negligible drop Industrial valves high drop, cavitation, erosion at hundreds m/s
Response 15 Hz minimum, sinusoidal not square Liquid needs time, square wave boils fluid, needs encoder

Three Topologies - Ball, Balanced Poppet, Blade

  • Ball valves are the balls of a rocket, 90 degree rotation only, throttlable.
  • Poppet valve is most complex, brain-damaging, but can be built as balanced valve.
  • Blade valves are end-it-all, emergency cutoff, unscheduled kaboom events.
  • Other topologies are just variations of these, if you understand these, you understand all.

Ball Valve - 90 Degree, Full Port, Pipe Is Pipe

Now, what about topology? Now, let them be. There is a ginormously long list of the topology, but I'm going to focus on some interesting ones. One is ball valves. Now ball valves are the balls of a rocket. They have certain advantages. First advantage is 90 degree rotation only. Meaning done. They do not need 180°. They just need 90°, just 90° rotation gives you from 0 to 100%. And yes, it is throttlable, meaning you can have it at 45°. So it is there.

And when it's fully open, it is full port. This is the best part about it. Meaning the pipe is just pipe. Meaning propellant will flow through it, and it will not notice, hey, wait a minute, I went through a valve. It does not even notice that there was a valve, it's just like it's a pipe, like when it's fully open, it's a pipe. So zero, you know, what we call flow restriction, zero pressure drop. So these are good.

And in terms of mechanical sealing, because it's a curvature surface, and it's generally always in contact, it's relatively easy to seal, assuming you have the material for it. The seal itself is, the mechanical part of the seal, easy. Making sure that the seal material works at cryogenic temperature and not reactive to oxygen. Those are different hassle. Good luck with that. But geometry-wise, topology-wise, one of the best. So we use ball valves in lot of places.

Poppet Valve - Balanced, Floating, Fail-Close - Saturn V F1 Example

And then we use the most complex, brain-damaging valve known as poppet valve, because generally these things can be built in such a way, what we call balanced valve. What does that mean? This is from Saturn V F1 engine. This is oxidizer valve. I think this one is somewhere here. So what you have is, goddamn amount of pressure, right? Not only you have like a liquid pushing down, that gravity itself is creating pressure, you have all huge gas also pumping it up, so you have bonkers amount of pressure. How the heck you stop it?

You're like, okay, what if I put strong spring here? If you do, how the heck you will open it? So what they did is what you call balancing it. Meaning you will calculate the surface area where the liquid is applying pressure, so let's just say it's 5 square inch, okay, you're going to put a hole there. And that hole will go on the back side, on the second chamber wall. You will apply that force. It's like, okay, 5 square inch, 5 square inch. Meaning the moving part, the valve body, or the pin itself, it's balanced. It's being pushed from both sides.

At this point in time, it's floating. Meaning if you want to move it, like if you have a rod and you're just trying to move it, it will move without any issue. You can move it with human hand if it's balanced that well. But again, it can be done. Now instead of requiring hundreds of tons of power, you only need like, you know, few kilograms of force. And they generally put spring. Why they put spring? This is one critical aspect of all rocketry design, it must fail known.

As in, something happened, what would be the state of it? Meaning wiring failure, hydraulic failure, or pneumatic failure, whatever happened, like somebody sneezed, what will valve do in that sort of scenario? Because it's a balanced system, they generally have a spring pack. The spring pack is only there to make sure that this driver section, if it is kaboom, right, like somebody booms this, no problem. The spring will make sure that valve will always fail-close.

Meaning to open it, it's an intentional command. Any electrical failure, any pneumatic failure will set this close. It will never fail, I do not know. You do not want a pad abort scenario where it's like, oh, I'm still leaking liquid oxygen. So you have to make sure this is how it works. So this, and this is the full fluid cavity, and not to mention, you also have to make sure that there is a boil-off vent.

Like in this design, no matter how good you are, when you close it, some amount of liquid oxygen would be there, or what if a pad abort scenario happened, there would be lot of oxygen there, so you have a purge check valve. That's how they check where the valves are opening or closing, or all that, because this also helps you to notice, like, let's just say valve is closed for 5 minutes, and you're still detecting oxygen, the initial boil-off will fade away, and you will run calculation, like how much leakage should be there, and you're detecting way too much, that means the seal has failed.

If you're seeing, like, okay, valve was not working correctly, that's how they detected these points, where there should not be any boil-off gas beyond the margin, it's beyond the margin, it's like, wo, the valve is leaky, valve is pissing, so turn it off. So this is a poppet valve, and they are, what you call, bit more easy to drive, simply because it's balanced. It's even easier than ball valve. It's super easy to drive. Like you can just pressure open, pressure close.

Best for self-sealing, because it utilizes the pressure itself to seal. For example, exactly how your car engine exhaust poppets work. It's exact same thing. The pressure in the chamber seals it. You do not have to do anything extra to it. So the sealing part, great. Pressure balance makes it actually actionable. That's also great. It is messy to deal with. Again, it's like, it's engineering hard work.

Blade Valve - Pang, Emergency Cutoff

And then you have blade valves. Blade valves are like end it all. Like the end, rocket in the end, it doesn't even matter. That's kind of blade valves are like. So you have a pipe, you'll have a slide area, and you will have a shear gear, which is like pang. Now why would you do that? Those are generally done when you have emergency cutoffs, or unscheduled kaboom events. In those sort of scenario, where it's like, and you're like, okay, why would you have that extra valve?

Emergency cutoff can be done in a safe scenario, in those sort of time, you would love a valve that is like, I got this, fam, like, I got this. And second part is, whenever a rocket goes through like a kaboom event, where it's like, you know, range safety officer booms it, generally rocket does not have enough boom powder, where it's like kaboom, it does not have enough, it just has enough to weaken the structure and all that, but it does require certain things that causes catastrophic damage. The blade valves are really great at that, it's like, bam, the oscillation itself destroys way too many things from that action.

So topology, and there are far more topology, but if you understand these, others are just variation of those things.

Valve How It Works Best Part Hard Part
Ball Valve 90° rotation, 0 to 100%, 45° throttlable Full port, pipe is pipe, zero restriction, zero drop, curved seal easy Seal material must survive cryo + not react to oxygen
Poppet / Balanced Valve 5 sq in vs 5 sq in, floating pin, spring pack fail-close Self-sealing by pressure, easy to drive, pressure open / close Messy engineering, boil-off vent, purge check, leak detection
Blade Valve Slide + shear gear, pang Emergency cutoff, destroys flow path in kaboom event Binary only, one-shot, not throttlable

How You Drive Them - Finesse, Not Just Power

  • You don't need power alone, you need finesse, jackhammer that a surgeon is controlling.
  • Raptor need 600 L, got 600 L, throttle down to 50 L, relax, shut off, ballet dancer rock.
  • Not all valves are binary, blade is binary bam, many are throttlable.
  • Pneumatic uses helium, hydraulic uses turbopump power, EMA uses motor + ball screw.
  • Pneumatic binary by design, PWM is very recent, no older era had it.
  • Hydraulic robust, inbuilt lubrication, dampening, but heavy.
  • EMA is new thing, reduce helium, full control, needs minimum 400V battery.

Finesse - Jackhammer Controlled By Surgeon

Now we come to the critical part. Okay, that's the topology. How the heck you drive these things? You don't need power alone, you need finesse. Meaning, the best example I've seen is, it's a jackhammer that a surgeon is controlling. Meaning you're like, I need, Raptor is like, I need 600. I got you 600 L. Oh, it's like, whoa, I'm throttling down. Okay, I'm giving you 50 liters. Relax, brother. I'm going to shut it off. It's like, whoa. It's like almost a ballet dancer, a rock. So, finesse. You not only need like, you also need finesse.

And not all valves are binary. Lot of valves are like blade valves, binary valve is like bam. But many valves are throttlable, meaning you control on and off it. So the first topology to drive it is basically pneumatic system using high pressure gas, generally helium, and that's why you see so many goddamn rockets that have helium tanks. It's like, why they have helium? They are using it to drive something. It's not for tank pressure.

Pneumatic Helium - Binary By Design, PWM Is Recent

We used to have that, but again, generally if you look into Starship, it uses the gas itself, like methane. Methane will boil off, and then it will pressurize the tank. Oxygen, oxygen will boil off, pressurize the tank. So why the heck they need helium that much? It is doing actuation control. So pneumatic is done. Now pneumatic, if you have worked with pneumatics, you must have known one weird part about it. It's a binary by design, because again, air is a springy thing. So it will just either open or close. It's very hard to do, like, you know, open 10% or close 10%.

So what if you do need that, like that's a requirement. I need a pneumatic system, and it must do what we call partial throttle control. PWM, it's a very recent thing. There is not a rocket design from older era that has that, like, it's, it was unimaginable, because to do PWM, you have to do two things, not only you have to read the encoder, and you have to maintain, basically you have two springy forces that you are balancing each other. And again, when I'm saying like PWM, it's like, that's literally how they are burning helium away. So PWM is an option.

Hydraulic - Cuts Through Mountain, Dampening, But Heavy

Another is, what if you are dealing with some heavy puppies, like some old school ICBMs or Saturn V, if you need some really heavy puppies, where it's like, I can cut this, like, I got this, like, oh, this is hundreds of tons of power, it's like, I got this, hydraulic is your baby. But it does come with a problem, that you need a turbomachinery for it, meaning turbopump boot, almost like a old school bicycle used to have a small dynamo, that you just like, put it on the wheel, that drives the generator. Same thing here, you have the turbopump driving, and then it's like, what if, just, just give me a few hundred horsepower from it, so you push, push to stop it.

But again, that should trigger a red alert. It's like, how the heck will start a rocket if it needs fully functional turbopump to start? Well, to solve that, there is a tank. That tank has a membrane or piston, and on the other side of that piston, you have high pressure gas. So what we call stored pressure accumulators. These are heavy puppies, but they do give you enough oomph for few seconds. And some of the designs are literally boom powder inside it.

Meaning rocket sequence, go boom, that created enough gas, that it's starting to create pressure, and then you control everything, it can give you enough oomph for like almost 30 seconds. Basically idea is, by that time, your main turbopump is like, I got this. So it is robust, right, this thing can tank anything. Again, hydraulic, it cuts through mountain, like it's a minor inconvenience, so it's very robust. It has inbuilt lubrication, so meaning, other things, you can almost ignore it, it's like, I got this, I will take care of it. So it's very, and it has dampening capability.

This was very desirable. Meaning if your engine is like, the shock absorbers, like the hydraulic, like, I got this, bro, I got this, I got this. Dampening is a very, like, shut up, take money. So if your engine is like dampener, it's like, relax, brother, relax. So that's why we use hydraulics, or used to use them. But now they are heavy, that's the problem.

EMA - Motor, Planetary Gear, Ball Screw, 400V Minimum

Nowadays we use electromechanical actuators or EMA. Most systems are switching to EMA, because again, helium is expensive AF, and again, does not give you good throttles. Hydraulic, powerful, but brutal as hell, and then heavy as hell. So you have to have helium for other stuff, and you have to have hydraulic, and you have to have electrical. So people are like, okay, what if we throw away hydraulic? What if we reduce the pneumatic, and do as much as possible with electronic? Why?

You're going to need a battery. Battery technology have improved enough. And thankfully, a rocket engine only has to handle that puppy for few minutes. So yes, even like, you know, 【entity-Tesla¦canonical_name=Tesla】 car battery pack is like, I can tank like 8 minutes of brutal abuse, and even if you have to throw it away, that's a minor inconvenience after the rocket lands, and you do not want to do that with helium. Helium is a national resource, which we do not have enough of. So you cannot just like, you don't want to do that. I'm just waiting, when if Starship ever goes to like, you know, 100 launches a day, they will need to switch to nitrogen very quickly.

So electromagnetic system is basically, you have a motor, you have a planetary gear driving another gear train, and that is driving a ball screw. That ball screw gives you that, like anybody worked with CNC, they know what these are. And again, that's how they are making sure that, a, the rocket is not too heavy, b, it has redundancy. Hydraulics do have that problem, where it's like, one pipe failure, meaning all engines lose out. Here, even if, let's say, one actuator poops out, and you're like, okay, it's stuck in wrong position, computer is like, I got this, I'm going to shut the engine off, and others will take care. So this is desirable.

But does require high voltage battery, and when I say high voltage, I mean minimum 400 volt. Like, I rarely think these things will work at low voltage. Like, it's not that it can't, it's just that, all those savings of weight will go into copper, and copper is expensive. So these are, and it's also used in India, with what you call Small Satellite Launch Vehicle, they specified they are using this. It's the new thing right now, you want to reduce helium consumption, and you want full control. This is nothing pneumatic. Oh sorry, electromechanical systems.

Drive How It Works Good Bad
Pneumatic Helium High pressure helium, PWM balances two springy forces Simple, fast, proven Binary by design, burns helium, poor throttle, helium national resource
Hydraulic Turbopump + stored pressure accumulators, 30 sec oomph Cuts mountain, lubrication, dampening, robust Heavy, needs turbopump to start, one pipe failure = all engines lose
EMA Electromechanical Motor + planetary gear + ball screw, min 400V battery Full control, redundancy, light, no helium, 8 min abuse OK Needs high voltage battery, copper cost if low voltage

Valve Is Unforgiving - Upstream Of Everything, Sneeze = Kaboom

  • Valve is upstream of everything, nozzle, turbo, combustion chamber, all below valve.
  • Almost nothing happens above valve, everything happens below valve, barring structural failure.
  • Helium valve leak can drain pressure tank, bye-bye mission, surprisingly often.
  • Propellant leak starts fire, leads to kaboom, happened multiple times.
  • Stuck valve is Russian roulette, will go boom, how is roulette.
  • Single point of failure bottleneck, butterfly effect, cannot put valve on every tank, too heavy.
  • Seal material does not like Earth atmosphere, moisture corrodes, rusts, leaks, stranded astronauts.
Valve sneeze, rocket goes kaboom, the end. You do not fight it. It's abandoned ship.

Upstream Of Everything

Now the most brutal part about valve is, valve is unforgiving. Meaning valve is upstream of everything. Everything, like, what if your nozzle poops out? Valve is still above it. What if your turbo poops out? Valve is still above it. What if your combustion chamber, valve is still above it. So almost nothing happens above valve. Everything happens below valve, barring structural failure. So if valve sneezes, your rocket goes kaboom, the end. It's as simple as that. Valve sneeze, the end.

Helium Leak - No Orbit Correction, Bye-Bye Mission

So like, worst case scenario. It has happened to way too many often times, where it's like, you launched a, you know, payload to the Moon, or you launched a payload to low earth orbit. Everything is fine. It just has like a high pressure tank of helium, and it has basically monopropellant, is going to do the orbit correction, all that. It's like, then you command the orbit correction. It's like, sir, there is no orbit correction. It's like, why? Yeah, helium valve did not seal properly, and bye-bye your mission. Surprisingly often that happens.

Now to be fair, I do not blame valve engineer. Helium is leaky AF. So minor leak can easily drain, what you call, your pressure tank, and all your mission could be like, bye-bye. Has happened way too often. Another is leaky valve. What if your valve did, see, again, I'm talking about helium leak, that's not that brutal, but what if it leaked propellant? That will start a fire, and it will lead to kaboom, has happened multiple times. So that's one of those things there.

Stuck Valve - Russian Roulette Of Ouch

And stuck valve. Stuck valve is what we call a Russian roulette of ouch. How the heck your rocket is going to go boom? That's the thing. It will go boom. That's part is sorted. How, like, will it set other fire? Will the oscillation blow up the pipe somewhere else? Will the back pressure will create a fuel line to fall apart, which will become a blowtorch, if it will cause boom. It's, it's a Russian roulette. It will fail. It will go boom. But it's a bad thing.

And be mindful. Why can't we tolerate valve failure, simply because it's a butterfly effect variable, meaning there's a single point of failure bottleneck. You, valves are big, valves are expensive, they require a lot of wiring, you're not going to put, like, okay, every tank has a direct valve system to control it, you will have manifold. And, for example, worst case scenario is like, your helium tank, you do not want to carry multiple small helium tanks with their own valve, it will become too heavy, rocket might not even take off. So, it's one of those things that we have to bite the bullet. We have to design a valve that works.

Like, why the heck this did not work? You would think, oh, they had this problem. No, no, no, just valve sneezed. Like, they could not. Again, Boeing is blaming the supplier. Supplier is like, bro, we gave you a space rated system. You should have checked. That is the, because the sealing material, while it is good and fine, it does not like Earth's atmosphere. Lot of sealing material does not like Earth's atmosphere, especially the moisture in the air. It corrodes, or rusts out very quickly.

So I think they are using soft metals in those sort of scenario, and what happens, it leaks, it does not seal properly, that's why this stranded astronauts, nothing bad has happened, but the valves were like, nope. So let that be very clear, it is very unforgiving. Like, you can have a mission, full mission, where your engine sneezes, it's like, brah, who cares, but if you have a valve failure, it's like, yeah, bye-bye. They were lucky that this did not went into kaboom town, but again, now you understand why they did not risk it, as like, okay, astronauts in there.

It would have said, but it was unknown. The moment valves throws an error, it's like, yeah, no, no human will be near it. Valve goes away. The end. Bye-bye. Do not, you do not fight it. It's like, no, it's abandoned. Abandoned ship.

Discussion

Comments

0 comments

No comments yet. Be the first to start the discussion.

Related posts

More guides connected to this topic