On this page
Why SpaceX Created Supply Without Demand
- SpaceX made LEO rockets very cheap, Falcon 9 sweet spot is lower orbit, not geostationary.
- It made a factory that can produce 200 rockets a year while market demand was barely 20.
- That created a fertile ground for Starlink.
- Starlink idea is fiber speed internet anywhere on planet Earth, not basic dial-up.
- On paper it will have infinite demand, for rocket and for service, and it will be epic military asset.
Factory For 200 Rockets, Demand For 20
Hello reader, we're going to talk about satellite internet gold rush that is going on right now. So, let's dive deep into it. So, what's the idea here? Well, idea is very unique simply because 【entity-SpaceX¦canonical_name=SpaceX】 made Leo rockets very cheap. Let that be very clear.
【entity-SpaceX Falcon 9¦canonical_name=SpaceX】, while it is a good and competent rocket, its sweet spot is lower third orbit and not geostationary. So, he created a supply without a demand. Now, you're like, okay, what about this and all that? All of them were jump changed. Basically, he made a factory that can produce let's just say 200 rockets a year while the market demand maximum was barely 20.
So, that created a problem where it's like, okay, you have rocket systems, great, amazing. It's just that what's the use of it? Like, you'd be shocked how rarely they have to use it. So, that created a fertile ground. In that fertile ground, 【entity-SpaceX¦canonical_name=SpaceX】 itself came up with the idea of Starlink. Now, Starlink is that what if the whole world, as in like anywhere on planet Earth, you can get net or internet, so to say.
Fiber Speed, Not Dial-Up
And it won't be basic dial-up. Basically, you could do that right now today also. And whenever a catastrophe happens, earthquake, tsunami, those sort of things happen, these sort of things are deployed to take care of situation. But again, these are dial-up. Like, at best you can no video call. You're just going to like type, okay, this person has been accounted for. This person has been accounted for. Like, it's not that great.
But what if it was fiber speed, meaning anything above 10 Mbps and generally targeting 100 Mbps or more? So, at that point in time, it's useful internet. And on paper, it will have infinite demand not only for the rocket but also of the service itself. And it will also be a epic military asset, meaning you will at least have some amount of demand from consumer side fixed.
Like, you're going to get that. Basically, think it this way. GPS works globally and it's demanded everywhere where US Army is. Basically, take that and steroid it. So, that's the idea. So, what exactly is the problem with this sort of approach? Well, approach is physics-based, meaning what is the least amount of satellite you have to launch in order to cover the whole planet, right?
The least you need is three. Six is more than enough, but three. So, three is like lowest minimum 120 degrees apart. If you are 60 degrees apart, you have enough overlap and coverage and all that jazz. So, why don't we do that? Why don't we use geostationary satellite?
The Physics Problem: GEO, MEO, LEO - Latency And Coverage
- GEO is 36,000 km far, you can solve power and dish size, but you cannot solve light speed.
- MEO is worst defined orbit, 2,000 to 3,500 km, actually working at 20,000 km, still latency problem.
- LEO is only place where ping does not become hassle, but footprint is tiny.
- GEO: 6 satellites can cover planet. MEO: 100 is surplus. LEO: thousands needed.
- Internet is two-way, not TV. TV can tolerate 500 ms, internet cannot.
Geostationary: Far, Far, And Latency Is Law Of Physics
Well, they are far, as in 36,000 km far. That is far, far. And here's the deal. You might be like, okay, wouldn't that radio will become weak? Yes, but what if you are launching a very massive thing? Very massive dish cryogenically cooled and super sensitive and all that. You can solve almost all problem except one law of physics problem. That is latency.
You can have like, you know, hundreds of kilowatt of solar farm or maybe megawatt size farm just to make sure that it has enough oomph to do everything. It's just that you can't do anything to light speed. Light speed is slow. This puppy is far. Like you have to understand, take Earth's diameter, that is chump change compared to how far that is.
So, latency and be mindful, just to do a ping a counter, it will have to go 36,000 km, 36,000 km, 36,000 km, 36,000 km. At light speed, that will take time. That time is so much that unless the, let's say you are using a payment gateway, most payment gateway will shut down. Simply, it will detect something is going wrong here.
So, unless you have like, if you are using geostationary, it has to have a different authentication for that. So, latency is physics-based. And at that point, even if you're giving high bandwidth, people may not want to enjoy it because again, internet is two-way, not TV. TV is fine enough.
Even if you are communicating directly back to satellite, all you are doing is authenticating, not doing something drastic, so to say. So, it can be done very low energy-wise. And TV, even if it's taking 500 milliseconds, it's like one dish transmitting it, millions of dish receiving it, and it's one way practically. So, that latency is not an issue, but in internet it's a big ass issue.
So, that's why it's not that practical. Better than nothing, but not that practical. But, okay, you're like, okay, let's come down to MEO, medium Earth orbit. Now, medium Earth orbit is the worst defined orbit simply because it's way too wide. It starts from 2,000 up and goes as high as 3,500 km. Basically, it's almost touching geostationary.
MEO: GPS, GLONASS, Galileo, BeiDou Live Here
So, it's basically, everything between lower Earth orbit and geostationary. Uh so, it's there, but it has some utilization because the coverage is not very small. So, if done things correctly, you can launch few satellites and that will give you whole planet coverage. Um you will not have very high throughput, but you will have enough coverage.
And that's the reason why GPS, GLONASS, Galileo, BeiDou, all of those are in this exact orbit, medium Earth orbit. You need as little as 50, and 50 is much, like you can do it as little as 26. Uh 50 just gives you some hot spares and enough overlap, so you can have like, you know, dilution of precision, DOP, to make sure that you are like very crisp in terms of a positioning system.
So, why don't we use this for internet? It is good, but not that good. And we may fall when we are talking about something that is actually working, it's 20,000 km. You still have the latency problem. So, it's like, okay, math is very clear on this. You have to come to low Earth orbit, so the ping count itself does not become the hassle.
So, in those sort of you have to go to LEO. And you can see LEO signature, basically, the footprint of the radio is very tiny. That is the reason why you need thousands of satellite. Like, here you can easily take care of the whole planet by few satellite. Like, six satellite, you good. The poles will have some issue, but you good.
Um medium earth orbit, 100 you good. Like, you have surplus. Lower earth orbit, thousands. Like, thousands, multiple thousands you need in order to give enough throughput and enough coverage.
| Orbit | Altitude | Satellites For Coverage | Problem |
|---|---|---|---|
| GEO - Geostationary | 36,000 km | 3 minimum, 6 more than enough, 120 deg apart, 60 deg gives overlap | Latency, light speed, 4 x 36,000 km ping, payment gateway shuts down, TV okay, internet not |
| MEO - Medium Earth Orbit | 2,000 to 3,500 km definition, actually working at 20,000 km | 26 minimum, 50 gives hot spares and DOP, 100 surplus | Still latency, good but not that good for internet, perfect for GPS, GLONASS, Galileo, BeiDou |
| LEO - Low Earth Orbit | 300 to 500 km tight spot, some at 600 km | 1,000 sloppy, few thousand good, 10,000 great | Low latency, great, but tiny footprint, smaller coverage, need thousands |
LEO Tight Spot: 300-500 km, Self-Cleaning, Atomic Oxygen, Thousands Of Satellites
- Every player ended up in same tiny band, LEO.
- Good news: band is highest self-cleaning, dead satellite cleans itself in 2 years.
- GEO has no cleaning, must push to junkyard orbit above, too much energy, high hazard.
- Cannot go to 100 km, atomic oxygen corrodes, material disappears, reacts, not burns.
- GEO slots are owned per country, USA, India, Russia have slots. LEO is shared by everybody.
- Choke point of mathematics, cannot bypass it.
Self-Cleaning Band Vs Junkyard Orbit
So, that creates the issue that every player in this eco space where they are like, okay, we want to make a lower utilize basically a satellite internet. They have to do this and all of them ended up in this tiny band. Good news about the band, band is highest self-cleaning. Meaning, unless your system creates elliptical orbit, most things will poop out. If satellite goes poop, it will clean itself in 2 years.
In geostationary, there is no way of cleaning it up. You have to push it above it. Like, geostationary, above is this what you call junkyard orbit. It will take too much energy to deorbit it. And, not to mention, it will cross so many things. It's a very high hazard. So, we generally push things from geostationary. In lower earth orbit, it's low enough where nature takes care of it.
Although, let me figure. You might think, okay, why can't we make it very low? Rather than 300 km, what if we go to 100 km? Is that you have atomic oxygen there and that puppy corrodes things. Meaning, you have kept on tape atomic oxygen of 100 km altitude, gone. Your material will disappear. It will not burn. It will react.
So, fundamentally, you do not want to go very low because you will consume way too much electrical power just to provide the energy to ion engines just to fight it. So, it's stupid. We have done it. It's stupid. So, we are like, okay, let's 300 to 500. That's the tight spot. And, not everybody is targeting that exact point. Some are like, yeah, let's be at 600.
Yeah, it will reduce your throughput, but it will give you enough wiggle room that it makes sense. So, lower earth orbit, low latency, great, but smaller coverage. That's penalty. You cannot cheat it. So, you are whenever some company is looking into this, they are talking bare minimum with a like, you know, sloppy coverage, thousand. Good coverage, few thousand. 10,000, great coverage.
So, that's the problem. That everybody is like it's like you can't work around it. Geostationary, you have ironically a lot of benefit. Every country owns the geostationary space above their country. So, you have a lot of like slots. Especially USA has like a lot of slots. Even India has few slots. So, we get a lot of star Russia has a lot of slots.
But, when you're talking lower orbit, everybody is sharing. So, that creates the scenario. Thousands of satellite overlapping each other. So, this is the fun. It's like choke point of mathematics. You cannot bypass it.
How Far Ahead Is SpaceX: 13,000 Satellites, Starship And V3
- SpaceX has almost 13,000 satellites, took 7 years 4 months.
- Only few thousand needed for coverage, rest is throughput multiplier.
- Now hitting almost 160 launches per year, minimum.
- That is still not enough, system will fade out on its own.
- Starship primary function, no matter what 【entity-Elon Musk¦canonical_name=Elon Musk】 says, is Starlink.
- Starship can carry 60 V3 satellites, 3 rings per launch, cover planet in 125 launches, in 1 year.
- LEO satellites are consumable, best case 5 years, drag penalty, ion engine wears, solar storm cooks.
- Launches will never ever stop, constant refurbishment like body regenerating cells.
- V5 or V6 may freeze design, push life to 7, 8, maybe 10 years.
13,000 Satellites Is Throughput, Not Coverage
So, how far ahead is SpaceX? Because again, without that you do not understand how likely or unlikely it is to succeed. Well, 【entity-SpaceX¦canonical_name=SpaceX】 has almost 13,000 satellite. Now, let that sink in. You only need few thousand for coverage. If you have this much, you can guarantee throughput. That's the only difference that happens.
After a certain point, you are not adding satellite to give coverage. You got that is just that you're making sure if you have 10,000 people in this tiny concentrated spot, all of them can have a fresh satellite basically. So, that's the core essence. That's why they want to add like you know 30,000 satellite or 40,000 satellite. It's just throughput multiplier.
After a while, coverage is there. It's just that you are making sure that even the most concentration of dish you can have in one place, it still is good enough. So, 13,000 in low Earth orbit. And that took time. Like 7 years 4 month. Now, compared to every other country, this is light speed. But, it still took time.
And in recent year, they are hitting almost 160 launches, if not more than that, per year. 160 launches per year minimum. So, it took its sweet time. Now, here's the deal. That is not enough. Flat out, that system is not enough. It will eventually fade out on its own if they'd keep doing that.
Starship Is Built For Starlink
So, Starship was built. Starship's primary function, no matter what Elon Musk says, is Starlink. Everything about it is designed for Starlink. Now, Starlink is the workhorse that they have to deploy in order to make Starlink long-term viable. Let that be clear. Long-term viable. I'm not talking short-term viable. Long-term viable. Because it will carry a bigger satellite.
Basically, going from V1 to V1.5 to V2 to V3. And again, that's why they are increasing the satellite sizes. If each satellite can give more throughput, you don't need so many shells to guarantee like maximum throughput on every square kilometer of the planet. So, they are making V3 satellite systems. And it can carry upwards of 60 satellites per launch.
That is the biggest deal. Because again, shell is made by rings. Each ring has, let's say, 20 satellites. That means every Falcon 9 launch launches one ring. You have to do a lot of rings. Like hundreds of ring. Not even 100, like 60, 70. And you might want to stack them up in different system. But let's just say, if you have to do 60 at least. That's a lot of launches.
This puppy, on paper, can do three rings per launch with a bigger satellite. Meaning the grand total throughput of your shell would be exponentially higher. Not a little bit higher, exponentially higher. And you would not need that many launches. Meaning you can cover, given the same level of throughput, actually more throughput, you can do that in 125 launches.
Meaning if they do the same cadence as Falcon 9, nothing higher than that, they will cover the whole planet with V3 satellites very quickly. And that will only take 1 year. So, that is why they are pouring so much money into Starship. Without Starship, Starlink will fade out.
LEO Satellites Are Consumable, 5 Years Best Case
Because here's the deal. When you are talking about lower Earth orbit satellites, they are consumable items. Geostationary has very good track record. You launch it, you almost forget about it for 5 years or 10 years. Here, at best case scenario is 5 years. Like generally, some of the older designs, again, they were testing it out, so they did not even wanted it to be very long-lived.
But it can't be long-lived. It is way too close to Earth's atmosphere and that fundamentally creates a drag penalty. So, it's not going to last and you're like, okay, an engine? Ion engine is a wearable item. The item does wear physically not. I'm like, electrically, the etching, the plasma ion, all of that. It does physically degrade it and automation you will run out of propellant.
So, 5 years is not long enough and given you have so much the shell degrades. You have solar storm that will cook some of them. You will have basically solar storm push that will degrade orbit of some of them way too quickly. All of this means it's a continuous refurbishment. It's almost like a organic structure like how your body keeps regenerating old cells.
It has to do the same thing. Meaning, even though they would need 125 launches in day one, there's a very good chance by the time second year happens they would need to launch few more. Now, how would they do it? Will they replace the whole ring? Will they have a way of like some sort of bus that will go and deliver each of the satellite that has been damaged or something? That has to be seen, but it's going to require constant maintenance.
Like that way, constant. Like the launches will never ever stop. That's why I keep saying that. If they keep doing it on Falcon 9, eventually Falcon 9 cost will cost them so much that it's like, yeah, it's not economically viable. Like right now initial rush is there, so they're good, but it will fade down. You have to design for that. And again, without Starship that cannot happen.
Starship must work, must deploy 60 as in like three rings per launch. And again, each of these satellite also has to become better. Now, I do expect there will be a point, let's say V5 or V6, where they're like, yeah, let's freeze the satellite because the early stages you're going to get quantum leaps and quantum upgrades, but after a while it will reach saturation because of thermodynamics, because of radio noise and all that.
So, at that point they might finally decide, okay, this is as big as it can be, but let's just make sure the fuel tank is bigger. So, it could burn for longer. As in like 5 years could be pushed to 7, 8, maybe 10. 10 is pushing it, but not impossible. And again, that will delay how many launches they have to do in order to keep the shell functional.
So, this is SpaceX. They are very far ahead. They are also already working on Mark delivery vehicle and they have learned a lot of lesson in all of their satellites. That gives them a fundamental leap that others just don't have. It's not just like oh, launch the satellite. They know certain things that others have not learned yet.
The Race: OneWeb, Amazon, China, Jio, O3b, AST Space, Russia
- OneWeb 656 satellites, spotty planet-wide coverage, but no own launch platform.
- 【entity-Amazon¦canonical_name=Amazon】 375 satellites, has own big reusable rocket, 【entity-Blue Origin¦canonical_name=Blue Origin】, will catch up in 2 to 3 years.
- China 258 satellites, unbeatable in electronics, multiple private players, second launch cadence.
- 【entity-Jio¦canonical_name=Jio】 plus O3b target ships, naval system, data center backbone, not every customer.
- 【entity-Amazon¦canonical_name=Amazon】 targets everybody, one-to-one competitor to Starlink. China also one-to-one.
- AST Space targets phone as receiver, only 175 satellites, 10 to 25 Mbps, video call only.
- Russia Rosvet Bureau 1440, has rockets, but parts stalled due to war, satellite failed.
- India partnership with VI and AST Space, bypass licensing via mobile providers.
OneWeb And 【entity-Amazon¦canonical_name=Amazon】
So, what about this race? Well, here's the deal. You have European Union with a strong contender, which is OneWeb. OneWeb has a 656 basically satellites, which is significant as in like they can actually do spotty coverage planet-wide. Uh so, they are significant. Although they do have a penalty, they do not have their own launch platform.
Meaning they can come to 【entity-ISRO¦canonical_name=ISRO】 to launch it, they can come to ULA to launch it, they can come to 【entity-SpaceX¦canonical_name=SpaceX】 to launch it, they can come to whoever is left. Whatever is available, even Russian systems, they can come to and launch it. So, that creates a fundamental hurdle for them. Meaning they can't genuinely keep updating it. So, they have to make sure the satellites are long lived.
Another is USA, 【entity-Amazon¦canonical_name=Amazon】. Now, 【entity-Amazon¦canonical_name=Amazon】 is at 375. While I am saying it is the number is low, I'm pretty sure they're going to catch up to OneWeb very soon simply because 【entity-Amazon¦canonical_name=Amazon】 has their own rocket and it's a big rocket and it's a reusable rocket. Uh so, assuming the new basically 【entity-Blue Origin¦canonical_name=Blue Origin】's rocket launches before 2026 without going boom, there's a very good chance 【entity-Amazon¦canonical_name=Amazon】 in next 2 to 3 years will easily surpass all other.
Meaning it will only be secondary to Starlink. Simply because they have their own rocket system and have enough deep pocket that they can endure certain things. So, 【entity-Amazon¦canonical_name=Amazon】 is a serious contender. Then you have China, very serious contender. They're already at 258 satellites and they have certain advantages. Electronically, you can't compete with them.
Like you can do all you want to do and China is like which ways? Which ways? Like you can beat them in rockets, you can't even touch them when it comes to electronics meaning making satellites is minor inconvenience for them. And because they have learned their lesson, they have multiple private players. And the government is serious enough willing to pay enough that the launch cadence is growing exponentially and they are the second launch cadence rate compared to SpaceX so to say.
So they are a very sorted contender meaning they going to succeed in terms of making the system, in terms of deploying the service. How many real people will buy it, economics and all that, that's a different thing. But they will succeed because a nation is behind it. Then you have other also. For example, one is Geo plus O3b. Geo is a Indian company. O3b is a another European company.
【entity-Jio¦canonical_name=Jio】, O3b, And Whales Vs Everybody
Um and the idea is they're going to launch a few satellites and they're going to be a bit higher orbit, a bit higher like compared to all these and the target is not customer, target is ships. They're directly targeting naval system meaning that like OneWeb is also doing the same thing. OneWeb is not trying to match Falcon 9. Basically, they're not trying to match what Starlink can do.
They're trying to match a different kind of audience. They're like, hey, we're going to give you a data center backbone. We're going to give you a stock market backbone. We're not trying to nickel and dime every customer. It's way too inexpensive basically inefficient economically. Like they're directly targeting whales. Amazon is targeting everybody. Amazon is one-to-one competitor to Starlink.
Now, China space they are trying to directly do one-to-one to basically Starlink. And there are many more in planning stage and launching stage and in they have money that they cannot be taken out of. But again, I'm covering all of this because when I made this video, to best of my knowledge, these are the major players which have actually launched satellite, not just talked about it, launched it.
And Russia is also trying to do that. We might say Russia would be ranked technically third. Uh so they're also planning and launching it. However, they were stupid and they did Russia-【entity-Ukraine¦canonical_name=Ukraine】 war and because of that war there was a lot of lockdown that was done for supply chain. Lot of the expensive component, electronic component, was put behind lock and key.
Russia: Rockets Yes, Parts No
Meaning their satellite manufacturing department stalled. So even though they have rocket, they are the only third player that has their own rockets, they are like, yeah. So their in-house development, which was Rosvet Bureau 1440, I do not know why that is the name, why it is 1440. Rosvet means dawn in Russian apparently. They simply cannot manage.
They launched it later they launched it and the satellite failed. So there is a very good chance that they want to do it, they have the money to do it, it's just that they don't have the parts to do it. And yes, satellite parts are not something that you can I'm going to start today and it's going to be built tomorrow. That's not how it works. It's a very multi-decade long project.
And if you had the wisdom or knew that Putin is going to start this war, they would have done it beforehand, but they did not. So then now they are stuck. And this became very urgent after SpaceX got blocked in Russia, which mind you was a government job because 【entity-SpaceX¦canonical_name=SpaceX】 has two umbrella inside it. One is 【entity-SpaceX Starlink¦canonical_name=SpaceX】, which is common for public. Another is Starshield, I think they call it, which is for the military use.
That division is deciding what is turning on and off where. So Russia is working their ass off, it's just that it's hard for them. And you know, as they say, the hardest part of three-day military operation is the first five year. Now, what about China? Now China is working their ass off. And again, they have advantage.
They have multiple rocket companies coming online. They have multiple throughput, massive throughput in their electronics manufacturing. So they're they're like the goods, sir. They're good. They got this. And India is also doing lot of partnership. One partnership I talked about, another is VI partnership as in mobile company partnership with AST Space.
AST Space: Phone As Receiver
AST Space is a bit unique because they're not targeting to give you receiver. They're targeting to make your phone into a receiver. And they have some unique USB that allows them to do that very thing with very few satellites. Like as little as 175 satellites, they should be able to cover the planet. But be mindful they're assuming you're using your mobile phone to receive it and they're not going to give you like hundreds of megabytes per second.
The target is maybe 10 to 25. Basically, you should be able to do video call but nothing more than that. But again, if it can work in middle of nowhere, that is like shut up, take money. And again, they are working directly with the mobile service providers everywhere. I'm talking about VI because I'm in India. If you are in USA, I'm I think it's 【entity-Verizon¦canonical_name=Verizon】. Uh so, other places it's like 【entity-T-Mobile¦canonical_name=T-Mobile】.
Like they are working with different service providers so they do not have to deal with licensing and regulations. They directly you know bypass all of that hassle. So, the race is here. Again, hundreds of satellite. Be mindful before Starlink, this sort of number would be amazing on its own. So, this is real. This is serious and people are pouring money into it and everybody is launching in the same goddamn band, low earth orbit.
| Player | Satellites Launched | Advantage / Penalty | Target |
|---|---|---|---|
| 【entity-SpaceX Starlink¦canonical_name=SpaceX】 | Almost 13,000, 7 years 4 months, 160 launches per year | Own rocket, Starship for V3, far ahead, learned lessons | Everybody, throughput, 100 Mbps+ |
| OneWeb - EU | 656 | No own launch platform, must use 【entity-ISRO¦canonical_name=ISRO】, ULA, SpaceX, must make satellites long lived | Whales, data center backbone, stock market, ships, naval |
| 【entity-Amazon¦canonical_name=Amazon】 - USA | 375 | Own big reusable rocket 【entity-Blue Origin¦canonical_name=Blue Origin】, deep pocket | Everybody, one-to-one vs Starlink |
| China | 258 | Unbeatable electronics, multiple private players, second launch cadence, nation behind it | One-to-one vs Starlink |
| 【entity-Jio¦canonical_name=Jio】 plus O3b | Few, higher orbit | Indian + European | Ships, naval system |
| AST Space + VI / Verizon / T-Mobile | As little as 175 needed | Phone as receiver, bypass licensing via mobile providers | 10 to 25 Mbps, video call in middle of nowhere |
| Russia - Rosvet Bureau 1440 | Few, one failed | Has rockets, third player with own rockets, but parts stalled, supply chain lockdown | Trying to catch up, urgent after Starlink blocked |
The Ironic Paradox: Gold Rush - People Who Can Pay Don't Need It
- Developed nation that can pay for it does not need it itself.
- America demand is due to corruption, telecom took fiber money, did not deliver.
- India, China, South Korea, Japan, 【entity-EU¦canonical_name=EU】 have fiber, or 5G backbone.
- Remote locations don't have enough people, would be settlement not remote.
- Low-income regions can't pay, DRC 1.77, Madagascar 1.65, Zimbabwe 3.98 per person per day in 2018.
- Sustaining is very expensive, revenue has to be massive, short-lived asset.
- Army budget is not infinity, people fight for it, 【entity-Patriot¦canonical_name=Patriot】 missiles, B-2 capped at 22.
- Airplanes: 100,000 active, many players, 1 Gbps vs 100 Mbps, airlines want just enough.
- Expect 3 to 4 companies in future, 5 maximum, most will not be profitable.
America: Corruption, Fiber Money, No Internet
Now, here's the ironic paradox. That's why people are classifying this as gold rush. Is that developed nation that can pay for it does not need it themself. For example, why does America has so much demand for Starlink? Again, I'm not talking about people who genuinely need it. There are rural communities that need it. It's like why? Because corruption.
Like for example, American government had enough wisdom to understand that optical fiber cannot be played in middle of nowhere where you barely have enough fiber. The fiber itself will cost too much. This is 90s. And so the idea was government will bite the bullet and they will pay for the fiber deployment. And after that, you're just going to give service. So that way all constituency will have very good backbone internet connection.
They did work on it. They did pay for it. And all the telecom company was like if you. So, that's why America's does not have the internet that they should have and that they paid for. That's why there is so much hunger. Like every Tom, Dick, and Harry like you would look into lot of places where people are buying Starlink. It's a good town. Like it's a good sized town. Some even have airport.
And they're like, yeah, we do not have internet. I'm like, what the hell is this? I live in India and every village has fiber optic. I'm not joking. Multiple decent size of dwelling has generally two fiber service provider. In my hometown, we have two 【entity-Jio¦canonical_name=Jio】 and 【entity-Airtel¦canonical_name=Airtel】 and basically lot of local service provider. So, again, that's corruption. But what about China?
China does not have the same issue. India does not have the same issue. South Korea does not have the same issue. So, basically all the places that can pay for that generally has good fiber infrastructure. Russia, European Union. Most of the European Union has learned that and they are deploying fiber very quickly. The only behind schedule is Germany because somehow somewhere they were smoking something and they were like, we going to go on copper. Yeah, that was stupid.
So, you have to understand basically the people who can pay for it including Japan, they're like, bro, we have it. Like we have fiber. And the places that are hard to reach that does not have fiber, they have 5G backbone. I think like two mobile towers that are talking to each other without fiber. They are directly talking via 5G system. And again, enough of it is there that even in middle of nowhere you can have some connectivity.
And if you have deep enough pocket, you can like ask companies to lay fibers for you if you have the money or if you have demand high enough. So, that creates a scenario. Basically, people who have the money, they already have the options, good options. So, that means the number of pool that is available globally is very small. Very small.
Like it, the moment you remove that American crippling and look into to global picture like Japan, South Korea, India, China, and basically European Union, you'll find it's not that desirable. Like it is good good. Again, even in India, I do have a place where we are trying to extract what we call mountain water, like no joking, like spring water which is 7,000 ft up literally in the Himalayas. Yeah, that's the middle of nowhere.
And the water bottling plant does require internet. We barely have anything there. So, there are genuine reason why would you want to do this sort of thing, but the amount of people that need that goes down drastically. And be mindful, there's another thing, basically what if somebody uses your terminal and uses that to distribute internet. So, the customer count will go down drastically.
So, this is the main hassle. The people who can afford to build it don't actually need it. And it does need massive revenue to continue it. That's the core essence that you have to understand. Launching this, getting it done, that's one thing. But like you have to sustain it. It's a very what you call short-lived asset.
Sustaining Is Very Expensive, Army Is Not Free Money
Sustaining it is a very expensive thing. So, your revenue has to be massive. Only then you will might have some amount of profit. And you might be like, okay, armed forces can pay for it. I have seen this sentiment way too many times that people think that army budget equal infinity. That's not how it works. Like people fight for army budget. That's how tight it is.
And because be mindful, every other thing is also expensive. You can say, oh, we only need like 13 billion dollar for let's say Starlink. But they're like, bro, we have to make 【entity-Patriot¦canonical_name=Patriot】 missiles. Each of those missiles are like you know, hundreds of million. At that point in time it's like like you know, America did wanted to make B-2. They were happy with B-2. Like, bro, this is good.
And again, given the fact that how well it performed in the 80s, good. It's just that when they ordered 150, the bill started to come in. It's like, how about we cap it at 22? And again, China also has the same thing. Every country wants everything. It's just that once the bill comes it's like, yeah, yeah, don't actually have infinite budget.
And again, if any country has a brain, they will make love to Ukraine because Ukraine showed how little money can go how far when you are tanking technically the second ranked army. So, let that be very clear. Army would love to but they will be like, bro, for us if this is this is all we are doing like, you know, let's say India is paying Israel to make this.
They'll be like, bro, don't even launch 1,000 satellite. Try to do minimum as possible and increase the altitude rather than like being at 500 km, be at let's say 1,500 or maybe 2,000. Push to 2,000. Because again, we can't launch too many satellites and again, higher it is, the more longer it can live. And design it such a way that it while it will not have the throughput thousands and thousands of people terminals connected every square kilometer, it would be more than good enough for army use.
So, armed forces is not free money. It's a good customer but not like not that. And remote locations don't have enough people. This is another aspect that I've seen like, oh, there are a lot of remote people. No, those area won't be classified as remote if there were a lot of people. That will be classified as settlement, not remote. It's like saying, oil rig had thousands of people. It's like, no, it does not.
Like, you're not going to have like a Manhattan level population in you know, oil rig. It's not going to happen. Cruise ship might have that but again, cruise ship already has their own satellite internet. So, and okay, we're going to go and expand to all the untouched country. There are 200 countries and let's say 50 of them have good infrastructure, others do not. Okay, this is a good example.
Low-Income Regions Cannot Pay
And again, I'm sorry that the example is a bit old. It is 2018. Basically, the average spending power per person per day, it's not that much. Like, you're looking at DRC has 1.77. You have like basically Zimbabwe 3.98. All that Madagascar 1.65. It's not that much. Meaning, can they buy your Starlink? Not really. Can they pool their money to buy it? Yes.
Can they like I can easily see let's say certain places like DRC might have a school that is like, you know, bites the bullet and it's just like, okay, we're going to pay for it. But all the students are piling up as in their parents and then you are just getting one service connection there. So, the revenue that you're going to get from servicing this area will not be big enough. Like fundamentally it cannot be big enough.
It just cannot be because if it became big enough, other companies are like, bro, we just lay down the fiber there, man. And again, there are air fiber, there is 5G links. There's so many options that's like, bro, those are cheaper. And again, they have much grander throughput. So, low-income regions simply can't pay you.
It's almost like, you know, oh, we're going to cover all airplanes with Starlinks. Okay, cool, awesome. But here's the how many planes are there? 60,000? 70,000? 100,000 active. I'm not talking the grand total, active. Uh so, let's just assume let's just assume 100,000 flights. Okay. How many people are trying to cover that same thing? So many. You have Starlink, you have Amazon, you have OneWeb, you have Chinese.
So, that creates an issue. It's like and be mindful because there are so many players, even if each of their quality is not the same. Let's say Starlink can guarantee 1 Gbps per plane. And 【entity-Amazon¦canonical_name=Amazon】 can only guarantee let's say 100 Mbps per plane. Now, here's the deal. Because there is a competition, Amazon can almost cost cut Starlink as like, we can give you at just enough that legally we can say we are doing it because again, anti-competitive law, just enough. But cut under. But it's not high-quality.
Do you think aircraft company wants to pay for service? They're like, bro, we just give you enough that you are connected online. They're going to make sure like everybody is connected like a let's say if 【entity-Airbus¦canonical_name=Airbus】 A380 700 passenger, let's say all are connected. It's just that unless you're paying the premium, you don't actually have like, you know, video level. You can do your 【entity-WhatsApp¦canonical_name=WhatsApp】.
Do you think aircraft company wants to pay for service? They're like, bro, we just give you enough that you are connected online.
Paradox: 3 To 4 Companies, 5 Maximum, Most Not Profitable
So, that's the whole thing. Like, there is a genuine paradox here that it fundamentally the expansion cannot be contained. You cannot just like, oh, everybody. And be mindful like OneWeb is like, oh, we're going to directly target that. It's like, okay. Why can't 【entity-SpaceX¦canonical_name=SpaceX】 do that? Or why can't OneWeb be beaten by 【entity-Amazon¦canonical_name=Amazon】 or by Chinese company?
And I'm pretty sure China will take care of this because they have a lot of Belt and Road Initiative, meaning they have sunk a lot of money. It would be better for them to have like, you know, their own internet wires everywhere. So, there is a paradox, meaning can we do. Of course, we do. I expect at least three to four companies in the future? Of course. Even though hundreds are claiming, I only expect like five maximum. Uh would most of them would be profitable? Nah.
That's the, that's like, nah. That's just like, nah. I could see China like, hey, this is our asset. We are willing to put up with it. Uh Europe might be like, okay, OneWeb, we'll we're going to fund it because it's our own. But other than that, it's like, there's not that much demand. Like, financial capability of that demand. And you have better solution.
Discussion
Comments
Please log in to join the discussion.
Login to commentNo comments yet. Be the first to start the discussion.