On this page
Why We Need Something That Goes Boom
- Rocket is a very well choreographed dance, one thing after another in sync.
- Booster has to push, stay locked, then go peace I'm out, without damage, without kaboom, without hesitation.
- Separation failure is zero margin item, there is no recovery from that.
- Without this system, there is no rocket, flat out.
Rocket Is A Choreographed Dance
Hello YouTube viewers, welcome to my channel Science Technology. In today's show, Rocket Monday, we're going to talk about separation bolts. So, let's dive deep into it. Now, why the heck we need something that goes boom? Well, reality is rocket is what we classify as a very well choreographed dance. Meaning, one thing has to happen after another and all of it happens in sync.
For example, you could have the booster that is pushing you and it can easily go away from okay, I was pushing you, now I'm out. Peace I'm out. So you need something that is solid meaning you can trust, you can trust for it to transfer tonnage like few tons and it should be loadbearing, meaning all the vibration shocks, it's not just like pushing it, no, it has to push and be locked.
And when it needs to, when it needs to like peace I'm out, it has to part without damage, without going kaboom and without hesitation. Missions have been lost where things did not behave correctly. Like if you have payload fairing, it should go yeet. It should not go like h, and that has happened where it's like boom destroyed the mission. So no hesitation, no damage allowed.
Zero Margin Item - No Recovery
And it is what we classify as zero margin item, meaning your rocket engine, as long it's not just one engine. If it's a multi-engine rocket system, you can tank one or two engine pooping out or one engine sub performing at suboptimum level. However, separation failure is the end. Like there is no recovery from that. No matter how good your rockets are, if separation fails for whatever reason, the end.
So and missions have failed, like this is a Skyroots system where you can see clean missions have failed where separation event did not happen properly and loss of life. Now generally loss of lives are attributed more to like aviation sector, not a rocket section, thankfully. But you have to understand this is absolute scenario, like there is no oops, or not.
And not to mention, technically if you can count one Soviet Union loss of life in a space program because one of the deployment mechanism did not work, which generally relies on bolts. So there is a need for this sort of system, meaning we do not focus on it because it's not glamorous, but without it there is no rocket, like flat out there is no rocket.
Logic: Robust, Deterministic, 100% Fail Safe
- It has to be robust, carry load, clamp things down, survive vibration and Max Q.
- It must break and separate when needed, and it is deterministic.
- It is 100% fail safe, even partial deployment would give 100% success.
- You need excessive force, you can't unbolt a screw, you need controlled explosive boom devices.
- Boom devices are still king for big things, gentler systems are coming for smaller things.
Robust, Tied Down, Must Survive Max Q
So what's the logic behind it? Logically very simple. It's like you need robust. Whatever you're talking about, it has to be robust. It is carrying load. It is clamping things down. So, it has to be robust and it must survive vibration. So, this is another aspect. It cannot be just like ah, you know, it can't be a empty socket. It's like ah, it's like this, like you know, no, it has to be tied down.
So it has to withstand a launch vibration. It has to withstand Max Q stresses, all of that, and must break and or separate when needed, and it is what we classify as deterministic. I've only seen once in a while where rocket failed to separate, which was Starship, basically version one first launch, where the staging did not happen. That is so rare.
Like it was like rarely happens because the system is designed at deterministic, meaning it will not fail. It can happen early, but under no circumstances it will like oops, it's deterministic, and 100% fail safe, meaning even a partial deployment would give you 100% success. And generally to achieve this sort of thing, because you are talking about something that is seriously carrying load, you need excessive force.
Excessive Force, Controlled Boom, Gentler Systems Now
You can't unbolt a screw, so you need a controlled explosive boom devices in order to achieve it. Now it used to be the only way to do that. Nowadays we are going more into gentler systems that are utilizing either gas release system, motor-driven systems, spring systems, or whatever have you. But boom devices are still kind of king whenever you're talking about something big.
SLS And Shuttle Hold-Down Bolts - Two Boom Sticks
- Four bolts per booster, total eight bolts, for SLS and Space Shuttle.
- 【entity-NASA¦canonical_name=NASA】 drills two holes into bolt, packed with boom stick.
- Boom command has two independent paths, both double redundant.
- Even if one goes, threads will unlock, ideally both go kaboom.
- You will never see bolt in action, it is inside a white cap, to avoid debris damage.
- Never rely on one boom stick, it has to be two boom sticks with two electrical wiring systems.
Four Per Booster, Eight Total, Big Strong Puppy
For example, this bolt is from SLS and Space Shuttle. Basically, boosters were locked down to the plate. How there were four of these puppy per booster. So there were total eight bolts. Now this bolt is big puppy, like this is strong puppy. Here's the problem. How the heck you bolt it down? Okay, you have a nut. How you unnut it? You can't just scroll it back.
So 【entity-NASA¦canonical_name=NASA】 drills two holes into it and that hole is packed with boom stick. So the idea is when booster fires, when booster is completely certain that ignition has been done correctly, it sends boom command. Now boom command has two independent paths. One going boom here, or one going boom there. And both of the paths are double redundant. So no matter what happens, one of these will go boom.
The likelihood of both failing to go boom is like you know 9 to the power 9999. So and even if one goes, because again, if a nut goes like this, it's more than enough, the threads will unlock and it will work, and ideally both of them will go kaboom. Now be mindful, you will never see this bolt in action, even though there is a high-speed camera looking at that bolt separation.
Because it's a big item with a big boom charge, it can throw debris that could cause damage. So for that reason, it's inside a white cap. You will never see that. So this is what goes on to make sure that solid boosters go from I'm locked, like I'm locked, I got this, to I'm free. So this boom device cuts it. And that's why you will generally see two whole charges.
I'm locked. I got this. To I'm free.
Even if one boom powder is more than enough, they will never have one. They will never rely on one boom stick. It has to be two boom sticks with a two electrical wiring system. So the likelihood of basically, oh I commanded it and it did not go to boom, it should be almost zero, almost pure zero. So that's the logic behind it. I have linked the video down below. It's like it's a big bolt and you can see it in museum, real world real size, next to a human. It will give you more context what kind of size we are talking about.
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Vehicle | SLS and Space Shuttle |
| Bolts per booster | 4 |
| Total bolts | 8 |
| Holes drilled | 2 per bolt, packed with boom stick |
| Boom paths | 2 independent paths, both double redundant |
| Protection | Inside white cap, to avoid debris damage |
Payload Fairing - Flimsy, Messy, Must Yeet While Accelerating
- Fairing has to protect payload through atmosphere, sound vibration, supersonic air.
- Once above atmosphere, give or take 110 km, it must go bye, as quickly as possible.
- It must fall apart while second stage is firing, it is a live event.
- If you do not dump it, most delta V was dumped into fairing, fairing is wasted mass.
- Separation has to be very rapid, because rocket is accelerating, not just travelling.
- Old way: C4 packed, kaboom. New way: compressed gas, springs, more gentle, reusable.
- Spring system is more complex, many latches must disconnect at same time, no fail safe if one fails.
- Explosive licensing needs dedicated agent, initiators can go boom with minor oops.
Protect Payload, Then Dump It At 110 Km
Now another aspect that's like bolting to the ground is fairings. This is a very flimsy and messy thing to deal with because it has to protect the payload through against atmosphere, because not only there is sound vibration, there is atmosphere, you're pushing through, rockets are fast, like they actually are fast. So if you cannot have like supersonic air directly making love to your payload, there won't be a payload left, so it has to protect against that.
And the moment a rocket goes clean enough, as in above atmosphere, which is give or take 110 km, once it clears that point, it's like okay bye. Now this creates a very critical part. It must fall apart while the second stage is firing. Meaning it's not like Space Shuttle where Space Shuttle is in orbit, everything is fine, all the astronauts are double-checking everything, and then they calmly open the door. No, this is live event.
Meaning this thing has to be choreographed in such a way that booster can push through it, and that is by design. It's supposed, the moment you are clear of the atmosphere, generally you would be on second stage, and second stage would have just started firing, like maybe 10 seconds of firing, 30 seconds of firing, at that point you should be at 100 km above, once you're above 100 km and atmosphere drag is almost gone, you can open it up.
Now why you want to open it up, simply because that will allow your payload to go to orbit. If you do not, most of the delta V that your engine had was dumped into the fairing, fairing is a wasted mass. For that reason, it's like dump it as quickly as is possible. Like stage that puppy. Now that creates an issue. You are talking about something that is not only moving, it's accelerating.
It Is Not Falling Back, Rocket Is Accelerating
So the moment you disconnect it, you have something that is like you can see in that slow motion, like it falls back, but it's not falling back. It's the rocket accelerating, like it's not traveling, accelerating. So because again you are in orbit and like almost at orbital velocity, reaching that point above atmosphere. So if you disconnect it, it should float with you, right? It does not float. Why? Because rockets are designed to accelerate, and you just made rocket lighter. So it's there.
For that reason, these things, separation event has to be very rapid. It has to like disappear, like it's there, gone. So pyrotechnic systems are very old school. Now if you are in India and if you are in Bangalore, you can go and see this. This is PSLV payload fairing. It's in HAL airport, old airport road. There is a museum that has that. This is photo taken by me. It's there.
That now that whole scene is packed with C4 and it goes kaboom. So that flanges the whole thing, and that is powerful enough where it just like yeet, it just like nope, out of there. That's a what you call very traditional way of doing things, very old school way of doing things, meaning you will find that in all governmental rockets, but rarely you will see that used nowadays into any sort of new system, not even Falcon 9 has that.
Compressed Gas, Springs, Reusable, But More Complex
The reason is compressed gas can do that, meaning if you have a composite over vessel, you can do that with air, so that is becoming more useful. And if it's a small enough rocket, like Electron or Astra, those sort of things, you can just kick by springs only. So those are becoming more useful because A, they are more gentle, B, they are reusable. For example, in Falcon series, once those come back, you can recycle it without too much hassle.
But they are complex, meaning this is a simple thing, there is nothing other than electrical signal that will be on the base to go make them go boom, you don't have to do much more than that. In a basically spring system, you will have like multiple latches, you have to make sure all the latches disconnect at the same time, there is no fail safe, because again, even if one latch malfunctions, cap your mission, so it is more complex to build and assemble.
But again, if you are trying to reuse it, like Neutron rocket, where like hippo fairings, it makes sense. If you're not reusing it, it may not make sense. Although some people do utilize that for simple reason, because they do not want to deal with explosive licensing. Because again, that's a real boom material. You have to have one agent who's dedicated for that. Like you must have seen, in Starship, there are dedicated people who just go to the rocket and put boom powders there, termination charges. So same thing has to be done with all the bolts.
It's not just like hey, it's bolt in my pocket. No, be mindful, initiators can go boom. C4 is very hard to go boom. Initiators can go boom with minor oops. And some designs don't even use C4. They are like we raw dog it. They have raw RDX. C4 is RDX plus 40% plasticizer. I'm like raw RDX, like this is RDX. I'm like RDX is you sneeze wrong, it goes boom, and they're like no, that's our initiator, but I understand it, because they want to have absolute certainty. I said it go boom, it go boom.
So fairing is the issue. Now nowadays you can even see boom pusher, where you have pistons that are pushing. Now they will always have a threads or some sort of hinge mechanism that forces the fairing in this sort of, it has to be done that way, because mindful, rocket is accelerating. In those sort of designs, you will see fairings doing whoopty whoopty whoopty. So fairing separation is surprisingly violent. You might, no, it is violent.
| Fairing Method | How It Works | Pros / Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Pyrotechnic - C4 | Packed, kaboom, flanges whole thing | Old school, very powerful, in all governmental rockets, not reusable |
| Compressed Gas | Composite over vessel with air | More gentle, becoming more useful, Falcon 9 style |
| Springs Only | Kick by springs, Electron / Astra | Gentle, reusable, but many latches must sync, no fail safe if one fails |
| Boom Pusher | Pistons pushing, threads / hinge | Forces fairing away while accelerating |
Payload Adapter - Opposite Of Fairing, Gentle And Precise
- Fairing is yeet, adapter is gentle, precision is everything.
- Most satellites do not have own ion engine to fix a bad throw, except Starlink.
- Most places use springs for adapter, pyrotechnic bolts rarely used here.
- Motor rotates latch, latch undocks, spring tows it away.
- Never only one motor, always two motors.
- Two types of electrical coms, mechanism coms and payload coms, plus limit switches.
- Metals in space can cold weld, need coatings and lubrication, Galileo high gain antenna got caput.
- Separation confirmed by limit switch trigger and data com disconnect.
Starlink Can Be Thrown, Most Satellites Cannot
Then we go to payload adapter. Now payload adapter is completely opposite of fairing. Fairing is like ye. Now compare it to satellite adapters. Basically these things require precision. While yes, some things can tank a bit of abuse when you are launching them. It's just that, unless they have their thrusters on, their own thrusters, it's unwise. Basically, 【entity-SpaceX¦canonical_name=SpaceX】 can throw Starlink satellites because each satellite has its own ion engine.
And they design in such a way that ion engines are responsible for putting it into the right orbit. The rocket is just throwing it in the general vicinity, with right velocity, and the fine-tuning and the parking, all of that, would be done by ion engines. Most satellites are not like that, and even if they are, even if like let's just say you are launching a geostationary satellite, it has station keeping fuel that shall be used for station keeping, that shall not use the station keeping fuel for okay, you launched me wrong.
So for that reason, whenever you're talking a satellite, and you would notice that fairing is like quick event, satellite deployment almost looks like did it happen, it's like very gentle. So fundamentally, for this sort of system, most of places use springs. This is from basically Electron rocket, and this would be in your satellite. This puppy would be on the rocket. So they are both forced together. They are like forcefully married. So you send a divorce signal. It goes kabooming.
Motor, Latch, Spring, Always Two Motors
Now to make sure that this happens gently as possible, pyrotechnic bolts are rarely used. It can be used if it's a big satellite, or it does require like absolute line, like it's a big puppy, you might use pyrotechnique, but nowadays it's very rare in this stage. Pyrotechniques are rarely used. So what you have is basically a motor that is rotating a latch mechanism. That latch mechanism undocks everything, and that allows spring to tow it away.
So because again we are talking about motors, it could fail. There will never be an adapter that has only one motor. All of them will have two motors. One motor, two motors, always have two motors. In Electron rockets, the motors are on the inside, and you have wiring for that motors, and you also have data connection to the payload bus. For example, that's why this thing will be sold from Rocket Lab to you, like if you are customer, they will give you this whole thing.
Not whole thing, I would say, pretty sure they will give you, and it's like there is a wiring female plug, and there is a male plug, those plugs are your electrical coms with your payload, because after this is disconnected, only then your satellite will be like okay, it's on internal power. Before that, it can be on battery power of the rocket itself, or it could have, like depending on how you design it. But that also means there are two types of electrical coms.
One com is for the mechanism itself, that mechanism is like motor activation, motor limit switches, and separation switches. Now generally, when you're talking about metals in space, there is always a worry that it might weld to itself. Unlikely to happen if you have two alloys. Very unlikely to happen if you have good coating. But again, missions have been lost, where it's like, oh, metal touched metal, metal got welded, mission got corrupted.
Cold Welding, Galileo, Coatings, Limit Switches
Galileo, if I'm not missing, that's the mission where the high gain antenna got caput. So it does happen. You do not want two alloys to make love to each other. If they touch each other, like something like where you're forcing it, yeah, springs will be like, bro, it's welded, I can't do anything. So in those sort of scenarios, generally require coatings and lubrication and stuff, to make sure that under no circumstances it can weld to itself.
So they will have data limit switches, and again those switches will tell you, as you must have seen, separation confirmed, it's like how do they know, because cameras are very recent thing, but they always know how limit switch, limit switch will trigger the event, and the data com disconnect will be detected, that data telemetry has been disconnected. So all those things gives you absolute confirmation that payload has been kicked.
| Adapter Part | Detail |
|---|---|
| Separation style | Very gentle, springs, motor + latch |
| Motors | Always two motors, never one |
| Plugs | Female plug + male plug, electrical coms with payload |
| Power before separation | Can be on rocket battery power |
| Power after separation | On internal power |
| Coms type 1 | Mechanism: motor activation, limit switches, separation switches |
| Coms type 2 | Payload bus data connection |
| Cold welding risk | Metal touches metal, welds, mission corrupted, Galileo antenna example |
| Fix | Coatings, lubrication, different alloys |
| Confirmation | Limit switch trigger + data com / telemetry disconnect |
Same Toolkit In Civilian Life - Airbags, Slides, EV Pyro Fuse
- Same philosophy of boom powders, same toolkit, used in civilian, ground, air systems.
- Most civilian uses are once in a lifetime, rocket is use and throw, everything is once in lifetime.
- Car airbag, aircraft emergency slide, ejection seat, all once use, need instant, reliable work.
- Airbag is powered by rocket, not boom powder, slow burning, fills with gas, has hole, self-inflates, air curtain for one duration.
- EV pyro device physically severs high voltage link on collision, 400 volt or 800 volt battery disconnected, car bricked.
- Pyro charges unbeatable for instant reaction speed, very low cost, $5 for maker, $5,000 for you.
- Do not use RDX, let only NASA use RDX.
Once In A Lifetime, Airbag And Emergency Slide
Now we come to the another aspect of it, aerospace. Basically, this philosophy of having boom powders to do stuff is the same toolkit, so to say, utilized in civilian sector, and in ground, and in air systems. So basically, most of time, when civilian will deal with it, it is generally with things that are once in a lifetime. Now ironically, rocket is use and throw. So everything is once in lifetime.
But for example, your car airbag, while your car suspension has to deal everything for 100,000 km, your airbags only supposed to fire once in a while, or practically speaking, only once. There is no reuse on airbags. So they require something like that. And aircraft emergency slides, those are also once use, and after that they will re-evaluate the plane, repack everything, all of that.
So airbags, and be mindful, airbags are actually powered by not boom powder, rocket. They're powered by rocket. If you pay attention to any high speed footage, like proper high speed, you will notice that there is always a hole in the airbag. So they, and again, why don't they use boom powder? Boom powder will destroy everything. It will create a fragmentation hazard. A rocket, fast burning rocket, to us it will look like hey, this is just a boom.
For chemistry point of view, that is slow burning system. So it creates enough gas, gas, you know, fills up your airbag, and that vent makes that airbag self-inflate. You must have noticed that there is no airbag that is like full. Why? It's always has holes. It's like that's the whole essence, it's just a air curtain for one duration. It's like, and then it fades away. So in those sort of airbag scenario, nothing beats pyrotechnique.
Emergency Slide, Ejection Seat, EV High Voltage Disconnect
Emergency slide on planes, ejection seat, lot of loss of life happened because these bolts were not as reliable as they wanted to be, and nothing beats when you need something that once in a while, work. For example, if you have electric vehicle, you have something like this. This is what we call pyrotechnic boom device. Now if you have a collision with your electric vehicle, and your airbags, whatever, I do not mean like generally it should not fire if you have like minor fender bender.
But if you had something that trigger an airbag, this will go kaboom, this will physically sever the high voltage link, meaning this side would be disconnected from that side, meaning your electric vehicle will only have low voltage, the 400 volt or 800 volt high voltage battery pack would be physically disconnected, you cannot restart your car. And if you have heard, like a lot of people say that electric cars are fun and dandy, unless you go into fender bender, and it's like kaput. This is the reason for that kaput.
Your car might be literally a very, what do you call, who cares kind of incident, but if this was fired, yeah, your car is bricked, and then the car sellers, they will be like, okay, I'm going to sell your kidney. So fundamentally, pyrotechnic charges are unbeatable when you need something that has instant reaction speed. Meaning these things, if it detects an airbag firing, and that's the same circuitry that's triggering this, it will disconnect your system before your car gets crippled.
So nobody will get that 400 volt electric shock, and it's very low cost, surprisingly cheap, not from 【entity-Tesla¦canonical_name=Tesla】, 【entity-Tesla¦canonical_name=Tesla】 might be buying it for $5, you might be paying $5,000, but that's up to you. So this is the reaction speed benefit of it. So it's a very common, what you call, toolkit. If you know how to do that, it's a good toolkit. Although, do not use RDX, let only 【entity-NASA¦canonical_name=NASA】 use RDX.
Do not use RDX, let only 【entity-NASA¦canonical_name=NASA】 use RDX.
Discussion
Comments
Please log in to join the discussion.
Login to commentNo comments yet. Be the first to start the discussion.